02 May 2024

Daily Newsletter

Report: Slovakia Grants Refuge to Alleged Pro-Russia Campaigner

The Facts

  • According to a report published by Czech news outlet Denik N on Tuesday, Slovakia has granted temporary protection to Ukrainian-Israeli citizen Artem Marchevskyi, accused of running a pro-Russia influence campaign.

  • While his lawyer confirmed that Marchevskyi — the former general producer of the "112 Ukraine" TV channel — is now in Slovakia, the country's internal affairs ministry said an investigation into the case is underway.


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

This is a bold — and correct — move from the Slovak government. Despite attempts from the legacy media and unpopular establishment politicians to promote allegations from Czech officials as the ultimate truth, they are nothing but lies intended to slander people advocating for peace as if they had ties with Russia.

Pro-establishment narrative

It's concerning that Slovakia has offered Voice of Europe's Marchevskyi a haven as he is knee-deep in pro-Russia interference in the EU. Since the Kremlin needs local allies to spread disinformation and propaganda across Europe, the temporary protection may be crucial for their efforts ahead of June's European elections.

Nerd narrative

There's a 4% chance that Slovakia will be the subject of NATO action under Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty if NATO takes Article 5 action before 2040, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Colombia Severing Diplomatic Ties With Israel

The Facts

  • Colombia's Pres. Gustavo Petro announced Wednesday that the country will sever diplomatic ties with Israel, whose government he described as "genocidal" for its actions in Gaza.

  • Once formally notified of this decision, the Israeli ambassador to Bogotá and his staff will have 72 hours to leave Colombia. Previously, Colombia's ambassador to Tel Aviv was recalled and arms purchases were suspended.


The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Actions to isolate Israel will only hurt the countries that choose to cut ties. Israel's history of isolation hasn't hindered its growth, as the nation has prioritized its own interests, especially in matters of defense. Despite international alienation, the nation remains resolute in doing what it needs to do to survive.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Israel's unrestrained violence in Gaza has been compared to apartheid and makes it subjected to accountability by international courts, so it's no surprise the list of countries rightly cutting ties with Israel is growing. It's time for the US and other Western allies to pressure Israel enough for it to change course significantly.

Nerd narrative

There's a 76% chance that Israel will expand its ground invasion to the city of Rafah before June 1, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

US House Approves Antisemitism Bill

The Facts

  • Amid increased concerns over nationwide pro-Palestine campus protests, the US House on Wednesday passed the Antisemitism Awareness Act by a vote of 320 to 91.

  • The bill mandates the Department of Education to apply the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) definition of antisemitism when enforcing anti-discrimination laws.


The Spin

Narrative A

There's an urgent need to fight antisemitism on US college campuses. Violently antisemitic rhetoric has no place among students and young adults and by adopting the IHRA's definition of antisemitism this law goes a long way toward protecting the safety of Jewish students in America.

Narrative B

This is a bill that goes too far in defining hate speech and frames the issue in bad faith with vital missing context. It's important to fight antisemitism, but not at the expense of constitutional freedom of speech or in violation of one's religious beliefs.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that at least 114K US Jews will move to Israel by Jan. 1, 2050, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Georgia: Protesters Rally Against 'Foreign Influence' Bill

The Facts

  • Thousands of demonstrators protested outside the Georgian parliament on Wednesday as it passed the "foreign influence" bill in its second reading.

  • Though it will require a third vote to become law, the second plenary vote — approved with a vote of 83 to 23 — has cleared the way for the legislation to be passed in the coming weeks.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

The crackdown on the ongoing protests proves that the government doesn't promote democracy but fears it. After abandoning the bill inspired by Russia's repressive legislation following last year's massive protests, the government is now aiming to reintroduce it under a new label. The protests are comparable to the Maidan in Kyiv a decade ago — resistance needs to continue against the bill that will become a repression tool and bury Georgia's EU hopes.

Establishment-critical narrative

Protests are a basic democratic right, but in Georgia's case, they are directed and fueled from abroad. The West fears the law — the more liberal variant of a similar 1938 US law — as it leverages its non-governmental organizations to interfere in other countries' internal affairs. The West is seeking to create a Maidan moment in Georgia by employing established tactics to regime-change the democratically elected but disobedient government. Hopefully, Georgians will not fall into this trap.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that Georgia will control South Ossetia and Abkhazia before 2028, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

US Places Further Sanctions on Russian War Capabilities

The Facts

  • As many as 300 firms and individuals were on Wednesday placed on US sanctions lists in a renewed effort to blunt Russia's war machine.

  • Nearly 200 entities were sanctioned by the US Dept. of the Treasury and more than 80 were sanctioned by the US Dept. of State. Alongside entities from Russia, the list included roughly 20 names from China or Hong Kong, as well as non-Russian entities located in Belgium, Azerbaijan, Slovakia, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates.


The Spin

Narrative A

When Russian Pres. Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, the world came together to send him a message by placing many of the firms that prop up Russia's military under sanctions. While it could initially be argued that they didn't go far enough or they had little impact, two years later we're starting to see the measures restrict Russia's military as well as the livelihood of its general population, turning them against their leader. The sanctions are having a positive impact.

Narrative B

Despite the West's big talk on sanctions, ask any politician about dual-use equipment being used by Russia and they'll go silent. In fact, when you look at who is providing Russia with this kind of gear, you'll find that it's not firms from China or Iran — but indeed companies in the US and Europe. Part of the problem is that despite the wording of the sanctions, there are insufficient means of enforcing the measures. As a result, sanctions are having little impact.

Nerd narrative

There is a 1% chance that Russia will impose a total ban on Apple products before January 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Arizona: 1864 Abortion Law Repeal Clears State Senate Vote

The Facts

  • On Wednesday, the Arizona Senate voted to repeal the state's 1864 abortion law. Previously, the House last week approved the repeal of the law, which bans abortion from the moment of conception except to save the life of the mother.

  • Two Republicans joined all 14 Senate Democrats in voting for the repeal, which Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs is expected to sign into law. However, without court action, it would take 90 days after the end of the legislative session to take effect.


The Spin

Left narrative

This is a huge victory for the people of Arizona, who are broadly opposed to such a draconian measure. The overturning of Roe v. Wade revived a Civil War-era law that became part of the right's anti-woman crusade, but these efforts are backfiring. Even pro-life voters are voicing their displeasure with such inhumane measures.

Right narrative

It's disturbing that two Republicans abandoned their party to concede to the left and oppose a pro-life bill. Arizona has some of the strongest protections in the country for the unborn and the backing of the courts. It's sad there was more moral clarity in 1864 than in 2024 on this issue.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that 56.1% of US states will have Casey-era abortion rights on May 1, 2026, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Second Boeing Whistleblower Dies Suddenly

The Facts

  • A second whistleblower in connection with the safety issues surrounding the manufacturing of Boeing aircraft has died after a sudden illness, the man's family said on Tuesday.

  • Joshua Dean, 45, formerly a quality auditor at Boeing supplier Spirit AeroSystems, was among the first to raise concerns about manufacturing defects in 737 MAX planes. He gave testimony to a lawsuit and filed a formal complaint with the Federal Aviation Administration.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

This was a tragic death and sincere condolences go out to Dean's family. However, it would be foolish to speculate about the timing and circumstances of his death without sufficient evidence. There is currently no proof of any foul play.

Establishment-critical narrative

This is now the second death of a whistleblower in connection with this case. Both men were due to provide more evidence of the faulty manufacturing processes and their deaths at this time are deeply suspicious. The circumstances around these deaths need to be fully investigated.

Nerd narrative

There's a 94% chance that there will be a test flight of a full-scale heavy-lift cargo airship before 2031, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Biden Affirms Demonstrators' Right to Peacefully Protest, Condemns Violence

The Facts

  • US Pres. Joe Biden, making previously unscheduled remarks Thursday in the White House Roosevelt Room, said, ''There's the right to protest, but not the right to cause chaos" when commenting about pro-Palestine protests that have occurred on college campuses across the country.

  • At a time when many demonstrators have refused to leave the campus encampments they've built, and some schools are turning to police to clear them out, Biden called dissent "essential for democracy" but he added it shouldn't "lead to disorder."


The Spin

Republican narrative

Biden's late comments on these havoc-wreaking demonstrators weren't strong enough. The president attacked pro-Trump "MAGA" citizens with much more anger than he showed toward these protesters who don't back America's policies and have openly shown their disdain for him. This could very well cost him reelection, and the US can benefit from a stronger administration.

Democratic narrative

Biden is doing what he does best — calming a chaotic situation. He knows he's the president for all Americans, and his comments show his sympathy for all sides of this debate as long as they abide by the law. In a tenuous situation, Biden is toeing the line as a peacemaker as well as anyone could.

Nerd narrative

There is a 52% chance that Joe Biden will be re-elected President of the United States in 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

US Seeks Pledge by PRC, Russia Saying AI Won't Control Nuclear Weapons

The Facts

  • A US official claimed during an online briefing on Thursday that the US had encouraged both Russia and China to openly declare that nuclear weapons should always be in the control of humans rather than artificial intelligence (AI).

  • Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary (PDAS) Paul Dean stated that following public announcements by the US, UK, and France that any military nuclear decision would "only be made by a human being," Washington would "welcome a similar statement" by Russia and China.


The Spin

Narrative A

The inevitable dangers of AI are pushing us closer to another world war. Experts have repeatedly warned that AI could be the end of humanity, and the US' public acknowledgment of this potential nuclear-linked disaster is a bad sign. Umbrella AI regulation must be immediately sought if serious concerns are to be eased.

Narrative B

Implementing AI into the command chain of nuclear decision-making could change the world for the better if done correctly. Humans are just as capable of making mistakes as AI, and the help of automation within certain tasks could potentially increase global security. Nations must proceed with caution as we continue to become accustomed to living alongside AI, but there is reason to be optimistic if skillfully implemented.

Nerd narrative

There is a 36% chance that if there is a global catastrophe claiming at least 10% of the human population it will be due to AI, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Hamas Considers Latest Cease-Fire Proposal

The Facts

  • In a statement, Hamas political leader Ismail Haniyeh said he spoke with Egypt's intelligence chief Abbas Kamel and Qatar's Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani on Thursday, and Hamas is considering the most recent Gaza cease-fire proposal with a "positive spirit."

  • The proposal is said to include a six-week cease-fire, the release of 33 hostages, and an Israeli withdrawal after further negotiations establish "permanent calm." An unnamed Hamas official said part of the text is too vague, specifically regarding the end of the war.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Israel must be able to defend itself from terrorist attacks and the US is committed to preventing malicious actors from threatening Israel's legitimate concerns. But US Pres. Joe Biden's administration is losing its patience with Israel Prime Minister Netanyahu's intransigence, as the humanitarian situation in Gaza is rapidly getting out of hand. The situation must be remedied and an Israeli offensive in Rafah would only make the situation worse.

Pro-Israel narrative

In these critical times, Israel's military is diligently preparing for the possibility of an offensive into Rafah to dismantle Hamas' remaining battalions. Israel has fought a noble fight against Hamas' terror, and it seems imperative that Israel enter Rafah and finish this once and for all. However, given the complexities of the situation, Israel will calculate its next moves carefully.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Regardless of whether Israel is allowed to enter Rafah, the US is responsible for the atrocities Israel has inflicted upon the Palestinians of Gaza. Biden, worried about domestic political pressures, wants to make it seem as if he never fully supported this war. But from the beginning, Israel has been dependent on the US in its campaign to destroy Gaza and starve its people.

Nerd narrative

There's a 2% chance that there will be UN peacekeeping troops in Gaza on May 31, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter