09 December 2022

Daily Newsletter

China, Saudi Arabia Cement Ties

Facts

  • Saudi King Salman and Chinese Pres. Xi Jinping on Thursday signed a "comprehensive strategic partnership agreement" as part of Xi's historic visit to Riyadh aimed at bolstering political and economic ties.
  • The multiple strategic deals between the two countries included an MoU with China's Huawei Technologies on cloud computing and building high-tech complexes in Saudi cities.
  • The Saudi Press Agency reported that Chinese and Saudi firms also signed 34 deals for investment in green energy, information technology, cloud services, transport, construction, and other sectors.
  • Meanwhile, during the China-Gulf summit on Friday, Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman said that the countries had discussed the possibility of establishing a Chinese-Gulf free trade zone.
  • Uneasy with China's growing influence in the Middle East, the US termed Xi's visit an example of Beijing's alleged attempts to exert influence around the world and said it will have no impact on US policy towards the Middle East.

Spin

Pro-China narrative

Xi's trip is a fantastic opportunity for China to increase trade and cooperation with the Arab world, specifically its main oil-producing states. China and the Middle East are natural cooperative partners, as they have shared experiences in their respective struggles with Western imperialism. The Arab world has become tired of the condescending arrogance of the West and deserves a real international partner, such as China.

Anti-China narrative

Though Xi's trip to Saudi Arabia may seem like a routine summit, in reality, it demonstrates China's desire to export its own brand of high-tech authoritarianism. China's goals are overall economic in nature, but they also seek to empower the region's despots within a system of totalitarian capitalism. For China, ideals like freedom and democracy mean nothing, and economic and geopolitical interests trump all.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that there will be a mile-high building by February, 2042, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

READ FULL STORY

Report: Twitter Had 'Secret Blacklists' to Limit Users

Facts

  • Journalist Bari Weiss on Friday claimed internal company documents showed Twitter practiced different methods of censorship before Elon Musk bought the platform in October. She said that it created "secret" blacklists to limit users and restricted the visibility of "disfavored tweets" and certain right-leaning accounts.
  • This comes after Weiss, a former opinion editor at The New York Times who now runs The Free Press, was given access, along with fellow independent journalist Matt Taibbi, to a trove of company documents by Musk.
  • In the second batch of "Twitter Files," Weiss zeroed in on several specific accounts. These included Stanford University’s Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, conservative activist Charlie Kirk, and Chaya Raichik, who operates the "Libsoftiktok" account.
  • Weiss suggested that Twitter strayed from its original mission of giving "everyone the power to create and share ideas and information instantly, without barriers" by developing means to suppress identified users.
  • She included screenshots of the interface Twitter used to bar certain accounts, showing tags that indicate their restricted status and quoting several unnamed Twitter employees to support her claims. The most politically sensitive decisions were reportedly made by a group of top executives in the Site Integrity Policy and Policy Escalation Support.
  • Twitter executives, including the former head of legal policy and trust Vijaya Gadde and head of product Kayvon Beykpour, had previously denied shadowbanning, stating in 2018, "...we certainly don’t shadow ban based on political viewpoints or ideology."
  • Liberal media personalities on Twitter slammed Musk for giving Bari Weiss access to internal Twitter files, with some accusing him of conducting a PR stunt.

Spin

Right narrative

The old Twitter regime never thought someone would buy them out, let alone release their inner workings, which is why they repeatedly lied to the American people about politically-motivated shadow banning. They banned prestigious doctors from speaking about COVID, Libs of TikTok from freely exposing disturbing "gender-affirming care" for children, and conservative viewpoints in general. Entire swaths of the American political arena were wrongly silenced.

Left narrative

These "Twitter Drops" are embarrassing nothingburgers. Twitter's use of different methods of sanctions is not a violation of the First Amendment, which applies only to state actors. US Federal courts have ruled time and again, and as recently as 2020, that social media platforms are not state actors. What Weiss described is simply... content moderation.

READ FULL STORY

Reuters Poll: US Heading Into Shallow Recession

Facts

  • Economists polled by Reuters predict that the US economy is heading into a short and shallow recession in the coming year, unanimously expecting the US Federal Reserve to go for a smaller 50 basis point interest rate hike on Dec. 14.
  • Eight-four economists were polled between Dec. 2-8. Of the 45 that provided GDP forecasts, 27 predicted a contraction for two straight quarters or more at some point in 2023. Out of 48 that were asked, 35 said any recession would be short and shallow, eight said long and shallow, one predicted short and deep, and four said there wouldn't be one at all.
  • The predictions came after Bank of America CEO Brian Moynihan claimed a "shallow" recession was likely to come in 2023. The news came alongside an NBC poll showing 68% of US voters believe they're already in a recession, with 58% saying America's best years are in the past.
  • Nouriel Roubini, a New York University professor emeritus nicknamed "Dr. Doom" for his pessimistic predictions, has even warned that the S&P 500 could decrease by another 25% in the event of a severe downturn in 2023.
  • JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon told CNBC that while consumers and companies are in good shape, the $1.5T US consumers have in excess savings from pandemic stimulus programs may run out by mid-2023. The Fed last month raised interest rates by 0.75 for the fourth consecutive time, taking them to 3.75-4%.

Spin

Narrative A

It's very rare that prominent economists agree on a policy matter as important as interest rates, yet with wage inflation simply being too high there are several signs that a recession is looming. The personal saving rate is too low and savings are being used to finance current consumption alongside slowing factory activity. A hard landing is clearly coming for America.

Narrative B

Until now, the consensus economic view hasn't forecast a single US recession since records began in 1970. Within the market, it's not the inevitable that happens but rather the unexpected, and with the precedent of economists consistently being wrong surrounding recessions, maybe it's a sign that there won't be an economic crisis in 2023 after all.

Nerd narrative

There's an 8% chance that the first US recession before 2032 will lead to a depression, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

READ FULL STORY

Day 289: Blaze Destroys Moscow Mall

Facts

  • On Friday, a huge blaze broke out at one of Russia's largest malls in Moscow shortly after dawn, later spreading to over 18K square meters. Local officials said at least one person was killed. While a criminal investigation has been launched, there's been no suggestion of links to Ukraine so far.
  • However, Ukrainian attacks within Russian territory continued to be reported on Thursday; an explosion heard in the border region of Belgorod caused a fire at an undisclosed location. An explosion was also heard over Crimea, but Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that a drone was shot down before reaching its intended target.
  • Meanwhile, a new video emerged of Russian Pres. Vladimir Putin, in which he defended Russia's strikes on Ukraine's energy infrastructure. Some commentators and reports asserted that he was "drunk," though this couldn't be confirmed.
  • In the video, Putin said: "There's a lot of noise right now about our strikes against the energy infrastructure of the neighboring country. Yes, we are doing it, but who started it? Who struck the Crimean bridge? Who blew up the power lines of the Kursk Nuclear Power Station? Who is not providing water to Donetsk?"
  • "No one said a word about it anywhere," Putin continued, adding: "At all. Complete silence. Just as we make a move, do something in response, noise and crackle start over the whole universe. This will not prevent us from completing military objectives."
  • On the ground, Russian attacks continued to be recorded in the regions of Donetsk, Dnipropetrovsk, Kherson, Kharkiv and Sumy. Ukrainian officials said five civilians were killed and two more were injured in Donetsk, while eight people were injured in Kherson and four in Kharkiv. Pro-Russia officials from the Donetsk People's Republic (DPR) said one civilian was killed in the same time period.

Spin

Anti-Russia narrative

This invasion is an egregious violation of international law. Putin's ultimate aim is to restore the Soviet empire, even if it takes massive bloodshed and false pretexts such as calling the 2014 Ukrainian revolution after an election a "coup". This unprovoked attack is the latest chapter in Putin's Orwellian attempt to rewrite history.

Pro-Russia narrative

NATO and the US have ignored Russia's security concerns by breaking its promise not to expand eastward in return for German reunification. These concerns are legitimate and taking them seriously would have avoided the Ukraine tragedy.

Nerd narrative

There's a 52% chance that Russia will control any formerly Ukrainian territories other than LPR, DPR, or Crimea on January 1, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

READ FULL STORY

28 Oil Tankers Logjammed in Turkish Waters

Facts

  • On Friday, 28 oil tankers were waiting to cross the Bosporus and Dardanelles, with Turkey citing the ships' lack of insurance papers as the reason for the logjam.
  • This comes as the G7 countries, EU, and Australia have all agreed to bar shipping services, such as insurers, from allowing Russian oil exports unless it's sold at a low or capped price to deprive Moscow of wartime income.
  • The US Department of the Treasury says the cap applies only to Russian oil and doesn't necessitate additional checks on ships crossing Turkish territorial waters. Turkey says it's part of a separate insurance measure since the start of this month requiring ships to give proof of insurance for transit through the Bosporus strait or when calling on Turkish ports.
  • Ankara also stated that it's unacceptable to pressure Turkey over what it called "routine" insurance checks, adding that it could remove the tankers from its waters or require them to furnish new insurance letters covering their journeys through Turkish territory.
  • US Treasury Sec. Janet Yellen said that since most of the tankers are carrying Kazakh oil, there's no reason the shipments should be subject to Turkey's new rules. The EU said the delays are unrelated to the price cap and Turkey should continue verifying insurance "exactly the same way as before."

Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

While the US and Europe seek to pressure Turkey into obeying their rules rather than its own, the truth is that this new insurance verification procedure is aimed at preventing Russia from circumventing sanctions. If Western powers want to deprive Putin of oil revenue, they should be applauding the prudent move by Ankara.

Pro-establishment narrative

Since this is Kazakh oil and not Russian, there should be no issue here. With shipping companies claiming Turkey is asking for above price cap commission — putting them at risk of facing sanctions — the US and its allies have stepped in to resolve the issue and get oil moving westward again.

READ FULL STORY

Kansas Oil Spill Shuts Keystone Pipeline

Facts

  • The Keystone pipeline in the US has halted operations after more than 14K barrels of crude oil spilled into a creek in Kansas on Wednesday night. Federal safety regulators are investigating the cause, but no timeline has been given for restarting the pipeline.
  • Operated by Canada-based TC Energy, the more than 600K barrel-per-day pipeline ships heavy crude from Canada down to refiners in the US Texas Gulf Coast.
  • TC Energy has isolated the pipeline segment where the leak occurred and is using booms to keep the spilled oil from moving downstream.
  • News of the leak and subsequent closure of the pipeline prompted US oil prices to climb to $75.44 a barrel before retreating to $72.57.
  • The massive spill, one of the largest in the US in nearly a decade, could disturb the flow of crude supplies across the country at a time of market volatility due to fragile supplies.
  • Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, said he fears the leak could impact oil supplies to refiners in the short term, but if it lasts more than a few days, the consequences would be severe.

Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

The federal government refuses to learn anything from the numerous past leaks. Though drastically underreported to the public, oil pipelines leak all the time and cause accidents every year in the US. Keystone was supposed to be the safest pipeline ever built in North America, but inadequate infrastructure and lack of political will continue to put people, wildlife, and the environment at increased risk.

Pro-establishment narrative

There are reasons countries struggle to tackle these industrial accidents – there’s no such thing as a spill-, accident-, or sabotage-proof way to transport oil in massive quantities. The only way to prevent oil ruptures from becoming ecological disasters is to invest significantly in advanced monitoring and build double-walled pipelines. A safer design with zero clean-up costs is the sole cost-effective and environment-friendly measure in the long run.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that the Keystone Pipeline system will be extended by at least 100 km between US Pres. Joe Biden's inauguration and the end of 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

READ FULL STORY

US House Backs Record Military Spending Bill

Facts

  • On Thursday, the US House of Representatives approved legislation paving the way for the defense budget to hit a record $858B in 2023 — $45B more than proposed by Pres. Biden.
  • The House approved a compromise version of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) by a count of 350-80. This surpassed the two-thirds majority required to send the bill to the Senate.
  • The fiscal 2023 bill allows a 4.6% pay increase for troops. It also purchases weapons, ships, aircraft, and military aid for both Taiwan and Ukraine.
  • The Senate is expected to vote on the bill next week. It could potentially be signed into law by Biden before the end of the month, continuing a 60-year stretch of passing the legislation into law.
  • In 2020, the US had the highest defense spending in the entire world at nearly $767B. China was the second biggest spender at nearly $245B; India came in third at $73B.

Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

Beyond the headline-grabbing, non-spending provisions in this bill is a bloated budget that doesn’t even take into account inflation or what it’ll cost to replace weapons the US has given to Ukraine. The increased spending is just going to buy the military more weapons — and not even ones geared toward modern-day challenges and threats. This bill deserves more scrutiny from politicians, the press, and citizens.

Pro-establishment narrative

For the US to fulfill its obligations to defend its allies across the globe, and defend itself, it needs even more spending. Military spending as part of the Gross Domestic Product is actually less than it has averaged over the past 50 years. All branches are short of personnel, ships are poorly maintained, and it’s doubtful the weapons industry would be able to meet the country’s needs in case of a conflict. There must be a commitment to spending more on US national defense.

READ FULL STORY

2M-Year-Old DNA Reveals Greenland's 'Lost World'

Facts

  • In a study published this week in the journal Nature, a team of scientists successfully sequenced 2M-year-old DNA from the northeastern tip of Greenland. The DNA sequence is the oldest obtained on record.
  • The region is a polar desert today, but this discovery paints a picture of a lush and verdant Greenland 2M years ago, rich in biodiversity, including elephant-like mastodons, reindeer, geese, birch and poplar trees, and sea life teaming with algae and horseshoe crabs.
  • The findings stunned scientists, as only macrofossils from a rabbit and dung beetle had been discovered from that time period in Greenland before, which was 11°C-19°C (51.8°-66.2°F) hotter than today. Study lead Prof. Eske Willerslev suggested that the mixture of temperate and polar species living side-by-side was unprecedented.
  • Other surprises included the discovery of reindeer — which were thought not to have existed then, nor to have been able to survive in Greenland's ancient habitat — and mastodons, which are believed to have lived in North American forests. Willserslev said, "No one would have predicted this ecosystem in northern Greenland at this time."
  • Collected in 2006, the DNA samples were found at the mouth of a fjord at Greenland’s northernmost point. After numerous attempts, new DNA technology finally resulted in successful DNA sequencing and cross-referenced genetic libraries of plants and animals; the previous record was 1M years old.
  • Willerslev added that it may be possible to find fragments of so-called "environmental DNA" in samples as far back as 4M years. Scientists suggest that studying the deep histories of Greenland and Antarctica could reveal important information about previous times when Earth's climate changed rapidly.

Spin

Narrative A

Greenland's newly-discovered "lost world" is a close analog to what the region could look like if our current climate change trends continue unabated. This shows that plants and animals can evolve quickly in the face of a changing climate. The more we learn about similar eras of rapid change, the more information we have to anticipate and adjust to changes of the "hothouse Earth" of the near future.

Narrative B

Though a fascinating discovery, we can't extrapolate our climate future based on the lush Greenland of 2M years ago. The "lost world" ecosystem enjoyed longer warm periods between Ice Ages, allowing species to hang out nearby and repopulate Greenland at will. Many of the species that changed the face of Greenland back then are also extinct today, so it's better to appreciate breakthroughs in paleontology for their own sake without incorrectly projecting them on our climate situation today.

READ FULL STORY

Sinema Switches from Democrat to Independent

Facts

  • Arizona Sen. Kyrsten Sinema on Friday announced she has left the Democratic Party and is registering as an Independent. This comes after Democrats secured 51 seats in the Senate in the midterm elections. She will, however, continue to caucus with Democrats.
  • In an op-ed in the Arizona Republic, she cited increased partisanship and radicalization in both parties as her reason for changing. She also wrote, "Americans are told that we have only two choices – Democrat or Republican," but "most Arizonans believe this is a false choice."
  • She further stated her intention is "to be independent and work with anyone to achieve lasting results. I committed I would not demonize people I disagreed with, engage in name-calling, or get distracted by political drama."
  • Though her departure will likely mean she can vote less along party lines, she expects to retain her committee assignments. Sinema, who is up for reelection in 2024, has already angered liberals, who've hinted at putting up Arizona Rep. Ruben Gallego as a challenger.
  • Sinema, who took office in 2018 after the death of Republican John McCain, has often joined Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W. Va.) in blocking Democratic legislation. She will be the third liberal-leaning Independent senator, joining Bernie Sanders (Vt.) and Angus King (Maine), who also caucuses with Democrats.
  • During her first term, Sinema has bucked most of her party by helping block a corporate tax increase in the Inflation Reduction Act and has hindered attempts to abolish the filibuster.

Spin

Democratic narrative

Sinema’s career has been a giant metamorphosis, and Democrats could never count on her to be in their corner. This is just another step on her unpredictable path, and Democrats will have to continue to work around her harmful opposition to the filibuster, and her devotion to the Wall Street set, while accepting her support on issues that she agrees with them on.

Republican narrative

Democrats should take this as a warning about how far to the left they’ve moved. There’s less room nowadays for moderates, and those who don’t lean far enough left often pay the price by getting harassed while out in public. Sinema probably won’t be the last defector.

Cynical narrative

Sinema says her policy stances and voting habits won’t change. If she’s still going to caucus with Democrats, what’s the point of changing affiliations? Well, it’s all about her political survival. She’s highly unpopular with Democrats, but now she won’t have to face a Democratic challenger because the party won’t want to risk splitting the left-leaning vote. This isn’t about principles, it’s about reelection.

READ FULL STORY

Japan, UK, Italy Collaborate on New Fighter Jet

Facts

  • Italy, Japan, and the UK on Friday announced a plan to integrate their fighter jet development projects. This is Japan's first non-American, major industrial defense collaboration since World War II.
  • Japan wants to expand its relationship with allies beyond the US with an eye on potential military competition with China and Russia. Despite not being part of the project, the US Department of Defense endorsed Japan’s partnership.
  • The Global Combat Air Program plans to develop a sixth-generation fighter aircraft by 2035 and improve upon their current use of the British Typhoon fighters and Japanese F-2s.
  • In a joint letter, the three countries’ leaders stated, "We are committed to upholding the rules-based, free and open international order, which is more important than ever at a time when these principles are contested, and threats and aggression are increasing." Japan expects to double its defense spending over the next five years.
  • This collaboration is the second sixth-generation fighter design project in Europe in addition to a venture between France, Germany, and Spain. More countries such as Sweden could potentially be involved in the future.
  • Britain’s BAE Systems, Japan’s Mitsubishi, and Italy’s Leonardo are expected to be the key companies in the project’s development as the nations integrate their efforts.

Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Not only are Japan, Italy, and the UK combining their technological prowess to create innovative defense fighters, but the countries are also strengthening alliances to preserve global democracy. By building strong national advantages in their defense industries, these countries can build a robust system to support a US-led alliance.

Establishment-critical narrative

By drastically increasing its defense spending and engaging in large-scale military projects, Japan is creating an unstable security environment in East Asia. Tokyo is playing with fire by revisiting an interest in military activities that it abandoned for decades after World War II and throwing its lot in with an aggressive Western hegemonic order.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that Japan will respond with military forces if China invades Taiwan by 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

READ FULL STORY

Sign up to our newsletter!