29 February 2024

Daily Newsletter

Greece: Transport Staff Strike on Train Crash Anniversary

The Facts

  • Tens of thousands of Greek transportation workers went on strike on Wednesday, seeking better pay and working conditions, in commemoration of the first anniversary of the country’s deadliest train crash on record, in which 57 people were killed in the city of Tempi.

  • While trains, ferries, taxis, and the metro experienced major disruptions due to the 24-hour strike, at least 20K people protested on the streets of Athens, and another 10K demonstrated in the northern city of Thessaloniki.


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

One year after Greece’s deadliest transit crash, we are no closer to justice for the victims and their families. Greek politicians and officials ignored cries to fix a broken transportation system for decades and did little to improve safety until last year’s tragedy that killed 57 and injured dozens more. In addition to their failure to deliver swift justice regarding the Tempi crash, government officials have neglected public sector workers who require a legitimate pay raise. Protesters are justified in demonstrating, and the Greek people deserve more accountability from their leaders.

Pro-establishment narrative

The Tempi train collision shook Greece to its core, leaving the nation grieving. The pain and anger of the victims and their families is 100% understandable, and everyone is demanding answers. The Greek justice system is doing all it can to get to the bottom of last year’s tragedy and deliver a definitive account to the people. The investigation goes beyond discovery and looks to deliver justice and accountability. There’s no way to undo the destruction of the crash, but the Greek government will do everything in its power to bring about justice and reconciliation.

See sources

SCOTUS to Hear Trump's Immunity Appeal

The Facts

  • The conservative-majority US Supreme Court on Wednesday agreed to hear Republican former Pres. Donald Trump's claims of immunity from prosecution for acts he committed as president.

  • SCOTUS set the week of April 22 to hear oral arguments, with a decision expected by late June. Last year, it rejected a plea from US Dept. of Justice Special Counsel Jack Smith to bypass the US Court of Appeals and hear the matter immediately.


The Spin

Pro-Trump narrative

This crucial case — which could determine the future of presidents to do their job free of fear of prosecution or coercive tactics by political opponents — is being fast-tracked to SCOTUS. The sides have just a few weeks to prepare their cases before the highest court in the land hears their arguments and then rules on this major issue.

Anti-Trump narrative

SCOTUS could hear this case today or tomorrow, but instead, it's slow-walking it, in effect dangerously granting Trump his immunity. This shouldn't be a surprise considering the conservative majority was shaped by Trump's three confirmed nominees. Now this case is unlikely to be resolved before the election, leaving voters without all the information they need and possibly leading to Trump killing it in his second term.

Nerd narrative

There's a 10% chance that a dispute that determines the outcome of the 2024 US presidential election will be decided by the US Supreme Court in 2024 or 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Ghana: Parliament Passes Anti-LGBTQ Bill

The Facts

  • Ghana's parliament on Wednesday unanimously passed a bill that restricts the rights of LGBTQ+ people. The legislation — reportedly one of the strictest in Africa — is widely supported in the West African country, though rights activists have condemned it.

  • The bill stipulates that anyone who identifies as LGBTQ+ can be punished with up to three years in prison, while anyone who creates or sponsors LGBTQ+ groups can be jailed for up to five years. The bill now heads to Pres. Nana Akufo-Addo for it to be reviewed and signed into law.


The Spin

Narrative A

It's outrageous that the so-called human rights organizations are meddling in Ghana's affairs and lecturing the nation. The law, passed unanimously by parliament, reflects the people's will. Like many countries in Africa, Ghana recognized that the West is pushing its permissive agenda which is not aligned with traditional values. Ghana should be applauded for resisting outside pressure and manipulation, and the president should sign the bill into law to protect Ghana's social fabric and culture.

Narrative B

The bill is a slap in the face to Ghana's LGBTQ+ community and a major social setback. No one should be punished for who they are, but that's what this disturbing law does. It's inconsistent with Ghana's tradition of tolerance, which has been rooted in society since pre-colonial times. This legislation threatens not only the rights of LGBTQ+ people but also those of all Ghanaians, undermining democratic principles. The president must reject the bill to safeguard Ghana's international reputation and economic process.

Nerd narrative

There's a 10% chance that Ghana will experience a successful coup d'etat before 2040, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Ruled Disqualified From Illinois Primary Ballot

The Facts

  • Former Pres. Donald Trump is ineligible to be included on the Illinois Republican primary ballot according to a county court judge who ruled Trump's actions related to the Jan. 6, 2021 riots at the US Capitol were in violation of Section 3 of the US Constitution's 14th Amendment.

  • This ruling follows a recommendation by the Illinois State Board of Elections hearing officer on Jan. 30 to dismiss a petition to remove Trump from the state's primary ballot.


The Spin

Pro-Trump narrative

This decision is disgraceful and a symbol of the continued hubris of woke election influencers attempting to prohibit Trump's democratic rights. While SCOTUS is destined to reinstate the former president back onto the ballots, the arrogance of a county court to interfere with a national election should worry everyone who values democracy.

Anti-Trump narrative

When majorities in the US Senate and House in 2021 moved forward with Trump's second impeachment, he was officially designated as an insurrectionist. The Constitution is clear about the consequences insurrectionists face. So, Trump should be removed from the ballots because a Trump run for America's highest office will place the US' democratic value system in irreversible danger.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that Trump will be removed or blocked from the primary ballot of any US state for a federal office under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

French Parliament Votes to Enshrine Abortion Rights

The Facts

  • After passing in the lower chamber of Parliament, the French Senate on Wednesday voted 267-50 to make abortion a constitutional right. Both chambers will vote again on Monday, and if the bill passes with a three-fifths majority, a referendum vote will be unnecessary.

  • One line in the provision states: "The law determines the conditions under which the right is guaranteed to a woman to resort to voluntarily terminating a pregnancy."


The Spin

Left narrative

While this vote certainly fits France's history of leading the fight for abortion rights, it was also a strong response to the US' reversal of Roe v. Wade. As emerging right-wing governments push to roll back women's rights, leading liberal countries in the West should take inspiration from France and work to codify this human right within their own governments.

Right narrative

The abortion debate in France has become so taboo that only the most ardent supporters of abortion on demand have been allowed to speak freely. Even pro-life advocates aren't calling for complete bans, but what they are asking for is the ability to educate the public on the alternatives to terminating pregnancies. Social services should be designed to give people all options.

Nerd narrative

There is a 56% chance that there will be a 10X growth in the number of legal abortions conducted in Poland by 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Chad: Opposition Leader Killed in Gun Fight

The Facts

  • The leader of Chad's opposition Socialist Party Without Borders (PSF), Yaya Dillo, was killed during a gun battle involving security forces near the party's headquarters in the capital N'Djamena.

  • This follows separately reported gun fights on Wednesday in which the government claims members of the PSF opened fire on the national security agency, adding that a member of PSF, Ahmed Torabi, tried to assassinate the head of the Supreme Court.


The Spin

Narrative A

Due to violent outbursts from members of the PSF, the past few days have been tragic for the people of Chad. Yaya Dillo led an attempted coup against the security agency, which resulted in soldiers returning fire and ending his life along with those of his fellow militants.

Narrative B

This was not a coup attempt by the PSF but rather Pres. Déby's latest attack on his political opponents. Weeks before this tragedy, Déby's intelligence forces and riot police surrounded the home of another opposition candidate and arrested him. If this was a coup, it was a coup against democracy in Chad.

Nerd narrative

There's a 45% chance that Chad will experience a successful coup d'etat before 2040, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Government Threatens Legal Action in SKorea Doctor Strike

The Facts

  • Junior doctors in South Korea are expected to continue their strike against the government’s plan to drastically increase the quota for medical students in the country, even as the government threatens to revoke their medical licenses and potentially pursue legal action.

  • The South Korean government set a Thursday deadline for medical interns and residents to return to work, but as of Wednesday night, 9K of the country’s 13K junior doctors left their hospitals after submitting resignations, while only 294 had returned to work.


The Spin

Narrative A

South Korean junior doctors have legitimate reasons to continue their protests, and the government would be wise to listen to them instead of threatening the nation's youngest medical professionals. Despite an aging population, the South Korean medical system is running smoothly, and there is no reason to impose a near-70% increase in the number of medical students. This rash and dramatic decision would only decrease the quality of medical education and promote unqualified prospective students. Instead, the government should work to fairly compensate medical interns and residents for their tireless labor and promote a system that rewards the next generation of doctors.

Narrative B

Trainee doctors have made their position loud and clear, and it is now time for them to return to work and resume providing necessary healthcare. The entire dispute revolves around the looming population troubles that await South Korea given its rapidly aging population, and the government is looking to take steps to avert a potential crisis. Meanwhile, young doctors don’t believe that the situation is dire and doesn't merit a dramatic increase in medical school classrooms. Regardless of whether there’s a medical crisis in the future, this strike is unnecessarily creating a medical disaster right now. The government has been patient, and it's time for doctors to come back.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that South Korea's fertility rate will be less than 0.747 children per woman in 2032, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Israeli Troops Fire on Palestinian Crowd, Over 100 Dead in Chaos

The Facts

  • Palestinian officials and eyewitnesses on Thursday reported that Israeli forces opened fire on a crowd of Palestinians gathered around newly arrived aid trucks in western Gaza City. Over 100 people were killed by the gunfire and resulting chaos.

  • Israel disputed the number of fatalities and called its actions "a limited response." Israel said that hundreds of people surrounded the trucks, leading to some being run over. Then, remnants of the crowd reportedly approached nearby Israeli forces, who first fired warning shots before shooting at whom they deemed a threat.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Due to the complicated nature of unfortunate incidents like this one, Israel must conduct a thorough investigation to maintain its moral high ground and demonstrate that it's serious about ending this war. The US has proudly stood by Israel in its war against Hamas' terrorist forces. However, with every passing day that a temporary cease-fire is not in effect, Israel loses the strategic gains it has made and isolates itself on the international stage.

Pro-Israel narrative

Thursday's tragic security incident was an unfortunate reminder of one of the many difficulties Israel is facing. Footage from the incident clearly shows hundreds of Palestinians aggressively attacking the aid trucks, and Israeli forces did their best in a bad situation. The international community, even as it forgets Hamas' Oct. 7 atrocities, must remember that Israel did not want this war and it has been forced to take dramatic action to ensure its survival.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Israel has committed yet another terrible massacre in Gaza only to be greeted with calls for an investigation and restraint. There already is more than enough evidence to suggest that Israeli forces fired indiscriminately into the crowds of terrified and hungry Palestinians barely managing to survive. Indeed, this massacre is another reminder of the lack of accountability Israel faces as it mercilessly continues its brutal campaign against Palestinians.

Nerd narrative

There's a 65% chance that Israel will have de facto power in the Gaza Strip on Jan. 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Texas Wildfires Engulf 1M Acres

The Facts

  • The Smokehouse Creek Fire in Texas has now engulfed over 1M acres, making it the largest wildfire in the state's history. Satellite images have shown it now spreading into Oklahoma.

  • Smokehouse Creek, which has burned over 400K acres in just Hemphill County and reportedly destroyed 115 miles (185 km) of powerlines, is the largest of three fires currently burning in the Texas panhandle.


The Spin

Narrative A

As climate change heats up the atmosphere, Texas has endured hotter and dryer summer and spring seasons, resulting in the wildfire season starting earlier and ending later. This has also caused a disproportionate amount of burned acreage in the Panhandle. This not only affects the environment we live in but has also raised Texans' homeowner's insurance by over 50%. The physical and economic damage from climate change cannot be overstated.

Narrative B

While wildfires have certainly gotten worse in recent years, part of the problem has been the government's decades-long policy of immediately extinguishing every fire everywhere. This practice is ill-advised because brush burning is often a natural way to rejuvenate grass and soil. Another reason fires have gained so much attention recently is that never before has America seen so many homes being built on the edges of forests. The government needs to take a step back and find new preventative solutions before more lives are lost.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that wildfires will destroy a total exceeding 10Mha of global tree cover in any year, by the end of 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

US Will Investigate Security Threat From Chinese 'Smart Cars'

The Facts

  • The US on Thursday announced an investigation into potential security threats posed by Chinese-made smart vehicles, citing concerns about technology that could collect data on US citizens.

  • The US Dept. of Commerce will carry out the investigation, which will focus on "connected vehicles" — ones that use network connections for features such as roadside assistance or GPS. The inquiry could lead to future regulations regarding certain car parts.


The Spin

Anti-China narrative

The US isn't playing games when it comes to potential security threats posed by Chinese cars, and this unprecedented investigation is a show of strength. It may be too easy for bad actors in Beijing to interfere with the operation of a car or steal data in the US, and the US won't stand for it.

Pro-China narrative

China has implemented strict oversight policies to prevent illegal data gathering, but Washington is again stoking baseless fears about a threat from China. This is nothing more than the US combining an investigation with its high tariffs to attack the Chinese automotive industry and gain a competitive edge.

Nerd narrative

There's a 12% chance that there will be a US-China war before Jan. 1, 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter