South Carolina Brings Back Firing Squad Executions

    Image copyright: nypost

    The Facts

    • On Fri., South Carolina gave the go ahead for condemned prisoners to be executed by firing squad, after the state Corrections Dept. confirmed that recent renovations to the death chamber in Columbia will accomodate this.

    • This follows a 2021 ruling that made the electric chair the state's primary method of execution, but gave convicted inmates the option to choose death by rifles or lethal injection when available.

    The Spin

    Narrative A

    Death by electrocution is cruel and unusual. As the death penalty is likely to remain State law for a while, inmates should have the right to choose a more humane alternative. The option of a firing squad is faster and more reliable.

    Narrative B

    It's misleading to claim that death by firing squad is a more humane approach. The reality is that this option is always gruesome, and doesn't cause instantaneous death. Worse yet, it's a contradiction to the gun violence that the law wishes to abolish.

    Progressive narrative

    Capital punishment is a barbaric affair that compounds violence with violence. It eliminates any possibility of rehabilitation, drains tax dollars, and forces the victim's loved ones to relive the crime. The death penalty is no more effective at ensuring a safe society than a life sentence - we need to reform our sense of "justice".

    Establishment split



    More neutral establishment stance articles

    Sign up to our daily newsletter