Artificial Intelligence

EU to Consider AI Facial Recognition Ban

MAY 10 2023·Updated JAN 8

Story

Image credit: Simone Padovani/Getty Images

The Facts

A European Parliament (EP) committee is set to finalize its landmark Artificial Intelligence (AI) Act on Thursday before sending it for discussion between member states, Parliament, and the 27-member bloc's executive Commission.
The Associated Press
Yet to be finalized is a proposal to ban the use of AI facial recognition technologies in public places, including matching faces with images from the internet. It would also ban using AI to identify emotional states based on facial expressions and predictive policing.
guardian
The center-right European People's Party is set to oppose the facial recognition ban, citing potential uses for fighting crime and terrorism, with members voting on that proposal separately from the others in the act. Exceptions will be made for medical and therapeutic use of the technology.
Euractiv
Rights groups have criticized the wording of the measure for potentially allowing AI to be used against migrants through location-based predictive policing, with Amnesty International arguing they would not be protected from "AI-induced harm" to the extent EU citizens will be.
EUobserver
The AI Act has been two years in the making, with lawmakers working to expand its scope after the release of ChatGPT. The act, one of the first pieces of AI regulation in the world, would also require companies to disclose copyrighted materials in their large language models.
Time
The act is expected to be passed by 2024 at the latest before a grace period to allow companies to adapt to the new regulations. Entities could be fined up to 6% of their global revenue if found in violation of the act.
The Associated Press

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Narrative A

The use of AI facial recognition could push mass surveillance to never-before-seen heights and risk severely violating human rights, discriminating against ethnic minorities and migrants, and ending privacy as we know it. It is imperative that the facial recognition ban makes it into the final draft of the bill with all applicable loopholes closed.

European Digital Rights (EDRi)

Narrative B

It would be wrong and reactionary to ban all forms of public biometric surveillance by making judgments based on technology still in its infancy. There are real steps that can be taken to address the public's fears, and it would be wrong to rob law enforcement of such a valuable tool. Dangerous criminals could be off the street and missing persons returned home in record time thanks to this technology.