Report: NYC Sinking Due to Skyscraper Weight

Image copyright: Getty Images [via The Guardian]

The Facts

  • According to a report published in the journal Earth's Future, New York City is sinking approximately 1-2mm each year on average, with some parts sinking twice as fast, due to the weight of its high-rise buildings.

  • The gradual descent of the city, being pushed by New York's more than 1M buildings weighing nearly 1.7T pounds, makes the city extremely vulnerable to natural disasters, according to lead researcher and geologist Tom Parsons of the United States Geological Survey.

The Spin

Narrative A

New York City has dealt with the effects of climate change and its subsequent natural disasters for years, and it's well past time the government takes the steps necessary to prevent further damage from storms like Hurricane Ida. The most important step would be to stop developing flood-prone areas in the first place and, after that, creating green spaces and replacing old, narrow drain pipes in already-developed areas will help absorb rainfall and pass it out into the ocean.

Narrative B

Immensely populated cities are one of the primary causes of climate change, but they can also be the solution. As the hubs of immigration, economic prosperity, and technological innovation, "megacities" have the opportunity to tap into the largest financial and talent pools in the world and engineer energy-efficient and walkable living spaces for everyone to enjoy. Climate change should be taken seriously, but it should be looked at through an optimistic lens regarding the potential for an urban future with smart design solutions.

Narrative C

New York City is not the prosperous land of opportunity it once was, climate change aside. Its overly-populated landscape is dirty and unlivable, and the fantasy of a vertical living paradise is quickly proving unrealistic. As more than a third of New York's population of 9M is now foreign-born, it's time to invest in those currently residing in the city and implement immigration policies to spread future immigrants to other parts of the country with lots of space. The Big Apple is a symbol of unwieldy urbanization.

Metaculus Prediction

Sign up to our daily newsletter