Israel

Vermont: Shooter of Students of Palestinian Descent Pleads Not Guilty

NOV 27 2023·Updated NOV 29 2023

Story

Image credit: Unsplash

The Facts

Jason J. Eaton, the man accused of shooting and wounding three college students of Palestinian descent, Monday pleaded not guilty to three charges of attempted murder.
Burlington Free Press
The shooting of the three 20-year-olds – one of whom is a legal resident and two who are US citizens – took place in the street near the University of Vermont in Burlington on Saturday evening while they were visiting one of the students’ family for Thanksgiving.
NBC
The victims – Kinnan Abdalhamid, who attends Haverford College in Pennsylvania, Tahseen Ahmed who attends Trinity College in Connecticut, and Hisham Awartani who attends Brown University in Rhode Island] — all remained under hospital care Monday with gunshot wounds.
Reuters
Awartani’s great-uncle Marwan Awartani, a former Palestinian education minister, reported Hisham “lost feeling in the lower part of his body” after one of the bullets struck his spinal cord. Brown University President Christina Paxson said Hisham is “expected to survive his injuries.”
Al Jazeera
Police on Sunday arrested Eaton, who matched the victims' description, after knocking on his door. Police Chief Jon Murad said Eaton answered the door and said "I've been waiting for you” before he held his palms up, admitted to having a gun in his house, and requested a lawyer.
Burlington Free Press
Nikolas P. Kerest, US Attorney for the District of Vermont, said Sunday that after the evidence is assessed a determination will be made as to whether Eaton also deserves federal charges.
Burlington Free Press

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Narrative A

Political, religious, and ethnic tensions have been on the rise since Hamas' Oct. 7 attack against Israel and the resulting bloody conflict in Gaza. An unfortunate consequence has been the rise of both foreign and domestic extremism targeting Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian, and Arab communities. This horrific incident is a consequence of soaring extremism in a polarizing geopolitical environment, and all stakeholders have a responsibility to tamp down toxic rhetoric that can lead to violence.

France 24

Narrative B

This is a tragic incident, and the public and media should not jump to conclusions. Eaton has a history of mental health struggles and was observed to be in a calm and positive mood before the incident. As more details emerge, the public will in due time learn about the motive and mental state of the alleged shooter and learn key context.