Accidents

France Fines Amazon $35M for Monitoring Employees Too Intrusively

JAN 23 2024·Updated JAN 26 2024

Story

Image credit: Nathan Stirk/Contributor/Getty Images News via Getty Images Europe

The Facts

The French Data Protection Authority ("CNIL") Tuesday fined Amazon's warehouse business $35M for using an "excessively intrusive system" to monitor employee performance.
ABC News
The Authority said the fine, at about 3% of Amazon France Logistique's annual (2021) revenue of €1.1B ($1.19B), was "nearly unprecedented." It said several thousand employees were affected by the systems.
France 24
The privacy watchdog found that Amazon France Logistique's policies — including tracking "inactivity" of over 10 minutes — put workers under pressure and breached EU privacy rules.
France 24
The Authority described Amazon's system of measuring every work interruption with such precision as illegal and "excessively intrusive." It also called out the firm's policy of storing such employee data for 31 days.
Cnil
The Authority also fined Amazon for having insufficient security on its video surveillance. The e-commerce giant, however, defended itself by saying the French watchdog's findings were wrong.
Bloomberg.com
Amazon previously faced similar issues at its UK warehouses. A British parliamentary panel report later viewed the company's surveillance practices as "micromanagement" and as causing distrust.
BBC News

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Narrative A

France is absurdly singling out Amazon for simply having a super-efficient warehouse management system. The logistics sector is peppered with similar measures and systems in place across the world. The scale at which Amazon functions requires an intricate system to keep the company's operations flexible and adaptive. Some tweaks can be made according to local needs and laws, but this massive fine defies logic.

TechCrunch

Narrative B

Measuring employee productivity to this extent reduces workers to robots that don't get breaks or social time at work. Companies should not be allowed to forget the humans at the heart of their operations. Signaling there's a problem if an item is scanned too quickly is just one example of poor work standards at Amazon.

ABC News