Yvette Cooper to reject call to broaden extremism definition
GuardianFEB 5
UK: Govt Rejects Home Office Recommendations to Change UK Extremism Definition
Above: Home Secretary Yvette Cooper on patrol with officers from West Yorkshire Police during a visit to Halifax Police Station on Dec. 20, 2024. Image copyright: Owen Humphreys/Contributor/PA Images via Getty Images
The Spin
Pro-establishment narrative
The current definition of extremism is vital for addressing radicalization and protecting the UK from ongoing threats. Far-right and Islamist extremism pose significant threats that are recruiting young people at an alarming rate, and they must be prioritized for the sake of UK security. While the definition of extremism will not change, the government remains committed to increasing efforts to counter dangers both online and in communities, safeguarding democracy, and public safety.
Establishment-critical narrative
The UK's current definition of extremism is flawed, focusing too much on ideology rather than actions. This risks policing thought and stifling legitimate political dissent, leading to unnecessary divisions. Extremism should be defined by actions that promote violence and harm, not by ideas alone. By targeting behavior instead of beliefs, we can better protect freedom of speech while ensuring public safety. It's time to shift the focus from policing ideas to addressing dangerous conduct.