Brigitte Macron to Scientifically Prove Her Womanhood in US Court

Brigitte Macron to Scientifically Prove Her Womanhood in US Court
Above: Emmanuel and Brigitte Macron during his first inward State Visit to the U.K. on July 9, 2025. Image copyright: Mark Kerrison/In Pictures/Getty Images

The Spin

Right narrative

This is a dangerous precedent where foreign leaders can weaponize American courts to silence legitimate journalism and free speech. The Macrons' attempt to drag an American journalist into Delaware courts — where she has no business connections — shows this is nothing more than expensive legal bullying designed to intimidate independent media. Regardless of the eventual outcome of Candace Owens' investigation, foreign lawfare against conservative American journalism is unacceptable.

Left narrative

The evidence will definitively expose how conspiracy theorists manufacture lies for profit and attention while causing real harm to families. Scientific testimony and photographic documentation will demonstrate the complete falsity of these malicious claims that have subjected the Macrons to global humiliation and relentless harassment. When someone knowingly spreads verifiably false information with reckless disregard for truth — the legal standard for actual malice — they must face consequences regardless of their platform size.

Narrative C

Demands for "scientific proof" of Brigitte Macron's womanhood misapply science and violate privacy as well as echo dangerous precedents of control, surveillance, humiliation and the policing of women's identities. Biological sex isn't something typically adjudicated in court via public medical details. Requiring photographic or medical evidence to affirm gender reinforces stigma, misuses legal procedure and risks personal harm. The controversy stems from defamation claims, but it also raises deeper, wide-ranging issues of identity and dignity.

Metaculus Prediction



Political split

LEFT

RIGHT



© 2025 Improve the News Foundation. All rights reserved.Version 6.16.0

© 2025 Improve the News Foundation.

All rights reserved.

Version 6.16.0