How a New Pope Is Chosen—and Who It Could Be
TimeAPR 20
The Election of a New Pope
Above: Pope Francis waves to the faithful gathered in St. Peter's Square during his Sunday Angelus blessing on World Youth Day on November 24, 2024, in Vatican City. Image copyright: Vatican Media/Contributor/Vatican Pool/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
The conclave represented a critical moment for the Catholic Church to choose a leader who will continue Francis's legacy of mercy and inclusion. Francis dramatically reshaped the College of Cardinals to be less European and more representative of the global church, particularly elevating voices from the peripheries. Pope Leo XIV must navigate complex challenges including secularization, financial transparency, and maintaining the delicate balance between doctrine and pastoral sensitivity.
Narrative B
The conclave's strict adherence to tradition ensures the selection process remains free from modern political influences and external pressures. This ancient election system, with its emphasis on prayer and discernment, protects the sacred nature of papal succession and maintains the church's independence. Pope Leo XIV should prioritize doctrinal clarity and traditional values while addressing the church's ongoing challenges in an increasingly secular world.
Narrative C
Francis was a terrible pope who corrupted Catholic values to advance his political agenda. Nonetheless, the Catholic Church has survived for almost 2,000 years, even when bad people assumed the role of pope. By virtue of having a papal office and well-defined institutions, the church has been insulated from the endless schisms seen in other sects of Christianity. Indeed, the church will have to clean up Francis's mess and return to a more grounded understanding of Catholicism moving forward.