03 November 2023

Daily Newsletter

Senate Approves Military Promotions Despite Tuberville Blockade

The Facts

  • On Thursday, the Senate approved Pres. Biden's nominees Adm. Lisa Franchetti and Gen. David Allvin, by a 95-1 vote, as leaders of the Navy and the Air Force respectively. Additionally, the Senate voted 86-0 to confirm Lt. Gen. Christopher Mahoney as the Marine Corps' No. 2 officer.

  • These confirmations were voted on individually so as to bypass Sen. Tommy Tuberville's (R-Ala.) hold on senior military promotions, which has been ongoing due to his objection to a Department of Defense policy for servicewomen seeking abortions.


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

Tuberville has boldly exposed the hypocrisy of the American political establishment, which has rightfully condemned the appalling murder of infants in Israel but unjustly supported the illegal use of taxpayer funds to get rid of unwanted pregnancies. Now, both sides of the aisle have come together to blame him for stalling military nominations when all he is doing is being a righteous citizen seeking to ensure compliance with federal laws.

Pro-establishment narrative

Whether you agree or not with the Pentagon policy that covers travel costs for abortions for service members and their dependents, it's a matter of fact that Tuberville's hold on military nominations has unreasonably used troops and their families as political pawns while undermining national security. Republicans and Democrats mustn't allow a single senator to punish the armed forces whenever they have a policy disagreement.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that elective abortion will be banned nationally in the US before 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

UK AI Summit: Big Tech to Allow Government Vetting of AI Products

The Facts

  • As part of the UK's first two-day Artificial Intelligence (AI) safety summit, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak announced Thursday that a number of technology companies had signed a voluntary document alongside 10 countries and the EU, allowing governments to safety-test next-generation AI models.

  • Eight companies — Amazon, Google, Open AI, Meta, Microsoft, Inflection AI, Mistral AI, and Anthropic — signed the document, alongside the US, the UK, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Korea, Singapore, and the EU.


The Spin

Narrative A

Despite facing skepticism prior to the event, the UK's AI summit was a success. The ability in and of itself to simply mediate conversations between the likes of the US and China should be praised, let alone the signing of shared communications and declarations. The AI safety agreement is a landmark moment, allowing governments to ensure safety concerning the latest technology within the fast-growing sector.

Narrative B

The outcome of the UK's AI summit was nothing more than empty rhetoric, voluntary declarations, and self-promotion. Alongside a drastically small emphasis on the opportunity for good that AI's potential holds, the summit ignored the immediate urgency for international legislation. Despite likely plaudits, the UK missed an opportunity to really lead in the regulation of the AI sector.

Narrative C

The UK's summit took a heavy approach to existential questions concerning doomsday AI predictions rather than the practical impact that AI may have on common workplaces and labor. The UK has demonstrated its strength as a leading force in the sector, however, such discourse between political, academic, and commercial elites is currently too narrow and leans too heavily upon the abstract threat of creating god-like intelligence.

Nerd narrative

There is a 60% chance of a discussion in mainstream media concerning an AI arms race in March 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Netanyahu Rules Out Temporary Cease-Fire as IDF Surrounds Gaza City

The Facts

  • Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in a brief televised statement before the start of Shabbat that he has told US Secretary of State Antony Blinken that there will be no temporary cease-fire in Gaza until Hamas releases all hostages.

  • Blinken arrived in Tel Aviv on Friday to push for short pauses in the fighting in specific areas to allow aid deliveries and other humanitarian activities amid threats of a wider war and mounting civilian casualties.


The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Though sympathy for Palestinian civilians is understandable since they are, to some extent, victims of their abhorrent leadership, an immediate cease-fire would neither be reasonable nor right. Israel will continue to avoid civilian casualties in Gaza as much as tactically possible but Tel Aviv must show strength so as to neutralize terrorists from Hamas and prevent further attacks from other Iranian proxies.

Pro-Palestine narrative

By urging for a "humanitarian pause" instead of calling for a complete cessation of hostilities, the US is intentionally aggravating the suffering of Gaza's civilian population. Rather than taking concrete steps to avoid an unprecedented humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, Blinken has engaged in inconsequential talks in Tel Aviv at a time when Israel has clearly stated that a cease-fire wasn't an option.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that the US will give at least $3.12B in aid to Israel in 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Russia Ramps up Drone Attacks in Ukraine

The Facts

  • Ukrainian authorities said Friday that Russia launched a wave of nighttime drone and missile attacks across 10 of Ukraine's 24 regions, adding that Moscow had expanded the number of drones it uses in its routine overnight attacks as winter approaches. Kyiv's Air Force said it intercepted 24 of Russia's 38 Shahed drones as well as one Kh-59 cruise missile.

  • Meanwhile, the Russian Defense Ministry said it unloaded "15 multiple-launch precision by weapons and unmanned aerial vehicles," targeting Ukrainian "missile and artillery armament depots, armament and military hardware storage facilities, and temporary deployment sites of Ukrainian troops, nationalists and foreign mercenaries." It said it wiped out production sites of UAVs, naval drones, and groups of foreign instructors and mercenary soldiers.


The Spin

Pro-Russia narrative

The ease with which Russia can destroy Ukrainian air strikes has been proven time and time again, and the same will be said once Kyiv receives its F-16 fighter jets. Based on how quickly Russia has taken out dozens of Ukrainian planes and more than a thousand of its drones, the elimination of F-16s will be a fairly straightforward military objective. There is no victorious future for the Western-backed Ukraine, only prolonged defeat and misery.

Anti-Russia narrative

Despite Russia's talk about overwhelming Ukraine in the air, this war has come to a static pause, with both sides putting up equally impenetrable air defenses. Moscow has had just as hard a time breaking through the thousand-mile frontline as Kyiv, which means the underdog Ukraine has, before receiving the proper air power it needs, already stunted the supposedly stronger Kremlin.

Nerd narrative

There's a 35% chance that at least 100,000 Ukrainian soldiers will be killed in the Russo-Ukrainian conflict before 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Report: SKorea Lining up Banks for $22B Arms Sale to Poland

The Facts

  • After hitting its statutory limits on import-export lending, South Korea is working to line up local banks to help Poland buy $22B worth of weapons as reported by Reuters .

  • According to an anonymous South Korean government official, "five local banks are reviewing a syndicated loan as a support measure" to help Poland buy South Korean rocket artillery systems and fighter jets.


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

South Korea is trying to profit off of war and global conflict. Despite the fact that South Korean law prohibits defense companies from selling their weapons directly to countries engaged in conflict, officials have their eye not only on the war in Ukraine but also on the developing war in Gaza. Seoul's loopholes of providing weapons to countries geographically close to Ukraine, like Poland, or refilling depleted US weapons stockpiles, allowing more American weapons to be sent directly to Ukraine and Israel, are insincere workarounds.

Pro-establishment narrative

Many countries around the world, like the US, are overextended with their foreign defense obligations. Countries are depleting their weapons stockpiles by arming Ukraine in its war against Russia, and this scarcity of weapons is not something they can easily or quickly solve on their own. South Korean defense companies can help fill this void. There is a need in this market that South Korea is more than equipped to fill.

See sources

Italy: Storm Ciaran Causes Deadly Flooding in Tuscany

The Facts

  • On Friday as Storm Ciaran moved through western Europe, local officials in central Italy announced that five people had been killed in Tuscany as a result of heavy rainfall and devastating riverine flooding.

  • Eugenio Giani, the president of Tuscany, declared a state of emergency and said, "It has been a long and complex night for the entire regional civil protection system."


The Spin

Narrative A

Storm Ciaran will be ranked among the top 40 most devastating storms to occur since 1980 and it should serve as a wake-up call to the dangers of climate change. Weather systems like tropical cyclones and broader patterns like El Nino are directly tied to sea ice and global temperatures. If we don't act soon these weather patterns will be irreversible and the impacts endless, and Europe is very much on the front line.

Narrative B

European governments have increased the speed of their climate adaptation plans. Not only are these nations aiming to reach net-zero emissions sooner, but they are also focusing on a multi-sector approach to infrastructure advancements that will incorporate resilient improvements in technology and nature-based solutions. Europe is at the cutting edge of adapting to climate threats.

Narrative C

It's easy to dismiss any extreme weather event as a consequence of climate change, but in reality, they're usually influenced by a myriad of factors that have nothing to do with it. More research is needed before we can establish any direct causal link between the two.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that the total damage incurred by climate change in the 21st century, as measured by its impact on GDP, will be at least 10.98%, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

New Zealand Election: Luxon Needs 2 Other Partners to Govern

The Facts

  • According to the final results from New Zealand's Oct. 14 election — released Friday — the country's conservative National Party must enter a coalition with two other parties in order to reach a majority within the country's 122-seat parliament.

  • Full results by the Electoral Commission show the National Party to have won 48 seats, with Labour New Zealand winning 34, the Green Party 15, right-wing ACT New Zealand 11, New Zealand First eight, and Te Pāti Māori six.


The Spin

Narrative A

Now knowing the final vote results, the requirements for what is necessary for Luxon to form a government are set in stone. Following hints that negotiations have taken place for weeks, excitement over the initial honeymoon of a new political beginning in New Zealand is inevitable. There is much hope that an agreement will come together before the electorate grows impatient.

Narrative B

Dashing hopes of Luxon forming an immediate majority with the help of ACT, the finish line of a New Zealand government continues to exist only in the distant future. Following a feisty campaign, there are genuine worries as to whether a sensible agreement can, in reality, take place. With Luxon noncommittal on a timeframe, New Zealand's politics could be destined to remain in purgatory for some time.

See sources

Elon Musk's AI Startup to Launch First Product

The Facts

  • Elon Musk's artificial intelligence (AI) company, known as xAI, will release its first AI model to a "select group" of people on Saturday, according to a post by the billionaire on X, formerly known as Twitter. Musk argued that in "some important respects," xAI's model is "the best that currently exists."

  • This comes as Musk, who recently participated in an AI-related discussion with UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, said xAI is a "separate company from X Corp, but will work closely with X (Twitter), Tesla, and other companies to make progress towards our mission."


The Spin

Narrative A

While Musk touts his AI endeavors as a pursuit of good, the reality is that creating a universal app for everything will inevitably bring about security and privacy concerns. Just ask the people in China, whose most important daily functions, from social media and phone calls to mobile payments and investing, are under the watchful eye of the government. Musk is likely going to struggle in his attempt to garner a user base willing to put their entire lives in his hands and AI-powered applications.

Narrative B

Elon Musk speaks about AI in both a thoughtful and benevolent manner. Through his immense understanding of technology, he wants "robots" to help give humanity a "universal high income" rather than everyone living together at the bottom. Furthermore, he has and continues to openly call for strict safety measures to ensure AI can be turned off if it goes awry. If the AI-powered "everything app" is going to be invented, Musk will undoubtedly lead the way.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that AI systems will become sophisticated enough that they can build, to some specification, a system that can itself do sophisticated programming by June 2026, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

FBI Raids Home of NYC Mayor Adams' Campaign Fundraiser

The Facts

  • FBI agents raided the home of New York City Mayor Eric Adams’ chief fundraiser Thursday amid a probe into whether his 2021 mayoral campaign received illegal donations from foreign nationals and companies via a Brooklyn-based construction company, according to anonymous officials.

  • Several agents entered the home of Brianna Suggs seeking evidence of whether Adams’ campaign conspired with the Turkish government and the company to funnel foreign money via straw donors — a third party that donates other people’s money using their own name.


The Spin

Narrative A

It seems like Eric Adams and corruption are so intertwined that it's impossible to separate him from his long list of questionable actions and even more questionable associates. While this probe is in its infancy, it points to a larger pattern of mismanagement that speaks to his ability to properly govern New York City.

Narrative B

Too many are jumping to conclusions about Eric Adams. The FBI’s warrant was vague, and agents have yet to even contact him about this investigation. Adams has shown that he is willing to comply with all law enforcement officials and takes any accusation very seriously. He shouldn't be considered guilty of a crime he hasn’t even been accused of.

See sources

Sam Bankman-Fried Convicted of FTX Fraud

The Facts

  • After a month-long trial, the founder of bankrupt crypto exchange FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried, was found guilty of seven counts of fraud and money laundering on Thursday.

  • Bankman-Fried — who maintains his innocence — was charged last year over allegations that he stole money from his customers at the FTX exchange to support his company, Alameda Research.


The Spin

Narrative A

FTX was seen as one of the more reputable firms in the crypto world, and its founder was considered a Capitol Hill darling, having donated millions to political campaigns and helped write legislation around cryptocurrencies. This predictable end to this shocking story — which will have ripple effects across the cryptosphere — will likely be the nail in the coffin for the industry.

Narrative B

Despite the myriad of problems exposed by the FTX fiasco, cryptocurrency can't be counted out as a viable long-term investment. While it will take work to rebuild trust in the industry, it can be done with the help of oversight, as this case has renewed calls for more regulation of this "wild west" financial space.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter