NYC Opens Tent Shelter For Asylum Seekers

    NYC Opens Tent Shelter For Asylum Seekers
    Last updated: 1 month ago
    Image credit: cbs


    • On Wednesday, New York City opened the Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Center, an emergency tent shelter that will temporarily house 500 people bused into the city by Republican governors. The decision comes ahead of the midterm elections set to take place in early November. [1]
    • The policy was announced over a week after Mayor Eric Adams declared a state of emergency in the city and warned that the influx of new migrants was overwhelming NYC's shelter system. As of Saturday, more than 19.4K people had entered the accommodation system in recent months. [2]
    • Authorities reportedly plan to use the facility located in Randall's Island as a waystation for single male migrants while determining next steps. Solitary male migrants—many from Venezuela—have been arriving several times per week at the main Manhattan bus terminal, mostly on buses chartered from Texas. [3]
    • This is reportedly the first in a series of makeshift relief centers that will be built in response to the migrant crisis, with projections that the city could spend more than $1B on emergency centers by the end of the fiscal year. According to officials, NYC spent $325K to set up the Randall's Island tent. [4]
    • Members of the City Council have criticized the selection of the site – a windy, difficult-to-reach island. However, officials argue that more than 80 potential sites were assessed, and it was concluded that a tent camp at the location would be more comfortable than existing shelters. [5]
    • Randall's Island is connected to the Bronx, Manhattan, and Queens by five bridges, while NYC's subway system is a bus ride or walk away. It's also home to the track and field Icahn Stadium, a psychiatric hospital, and a fire academy for the Fire Dept. of New York. [6]
    • Show more


    Democratic narrative

    This new facility will help New York City to humanely receive migrants that have been arriving from the southern border, allowing them to recuperate as well as reach their relatives. Unlike Southern Republican governors, who are causing this crisis by coercing migrants out of their jurisdictions, Democrats like Mayor Adams are working to support and assist these vulnerable people.

    Republican narrative

    Though Mayor Adams has long denied favoring migrants, and has vowed not to divert resources away from New Yorkers in dire need of services, the opening of the Randall's Island shelter has clearly showed the contrary. Compared to the spartan shelters — which house homeless New Yorkers — migrants will enjoy an accommodation wonderland that includes laundry services, three meals a day, and video games, all at the expense of the US taxpayer.

    Nerd narrative

    There is a 50% chance that at least 208K refugees will be admitted to the US from 2021 to 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

    Articles on this story