German Judge Sentenced for Striking Down School Mask Mandates

    Photo: Unsplash

    The Facts

    • A German judge who struck down mask mandates in two schools in 2021 has been handed a two-year suspended prison sentence for obstruction of justice, costing the judge his career and his pension.

    • Prosecutors say Judge Christian Dettmar “perverted the law” when he ruled against the state of Thuringia’s COVID measures requiring school children to wear masks, distance themselves, and be subjected to COVID tests. Dettmar’s order ended the requirements in two schools in Weimar.

    The Spin

    Establishment-critical narrative

    The ruling against Judge Christian Dettmar is a true mask-off moment for the authoritarian regime in Germany, which, along with many other “Western democracies,” seems determined to control its citizens. Contrary to the allegations, Dettmar based his ruling on scientific evidence that shows the negative impacts of lockdowns and masks on young children and is now having his livelihood compromised.

    Pro-establishment narrative

    Judge Christian Dettmar overstepped his bounds as a family court judge when he ruled on the legality of safety measures in schools. More importantly, he perverted justice when he allowed his political biases to interfere with his rulings. Dettmar had an agenda and used his position as a judge to orchestrate a case that would see it fulfilled.

    Articles on this story

    Sign up to our daily newsletter