Home
AI
World
Politics
Health
Crime & justice
Science & technology
Social issues
Sports
Money
Entertainment
Environment/energy
Military
Culture
Weather
Media






Home
Bias Split
Public FiguresControversies

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!

How our sliders workAboutContact UsNewsletter Archive
MediaFAQGlossaryPrivacy Policy
  1. Home

Hong Kong Protesters Win Partial Court Victory

  • #East Asia
  • #China
  • #Freedom of speech & expression
  • #Verdicts & sentences
  • #Freedom & human rights
  • #Politics
story
AUG 2023
Image copyright: Wikimedia Commons
story last updated AUG 2023

The Spin

Narrative A

This ruling shows that changes are occurring in Hong Kong. Just in the past few weeks, courts have ruled against the Hong Kong government's attempts to unfairly charge protesters and ban songs like “Glory to Hong Kong.” The 2019 protests and the latest string of court decisions have only added inspiration to the fight for democracy.

Guardian

Narrative B

While some may laud this decision as a victory, the sad truth is that nothing has changed. Peaceful pro-democracy protesters still have to serve in jail for simply participating in an “unlawful assembly,” and Macrae’s ruling only further legitimizes the government’s authority to dictate whether protests are legal or not and jail dissenters.

Doughty Street Chambers

Metaculus Prediction


Articles on this story

Hong Kong pro-democracy advocates have part of convictions quashed
GuardianAUG 2023
Hong Kong court rejects gov’t request to ban popular protest song
Al JazeeraAUG 2023
Hong Kong judge defies government’s bid to ban pro-democracy protest song
GuardianAUG 2023
Hong Kong judge rejects government request to ban pro-democracy anthem
Washington PostAUG 2023
Hong Kong court rejects government bid to ban protest song citing freedom of expression
IndependentAUG 2023