Verdicts & sentences

Norway to Fine Meta $98.5k Daily Over Privacy Breach

AUG 8 2023·Updated AUG 27

Story

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons

The Facts

Beginning Aug. 14, Norway's data protection authority will fine Facebook's parent company Meta 1M krone ($98.5k) per day for privacy breaches, including harvesting users' locations and using them for targeted advertising.
guardian
This comes after the watchdog, known as Datatilsynet, warned last month that it would temporarily ban Meta's tracking and profiling of users in the country, adding that if it continued the company would risk being fined.
The Register
Meta last week said it plans to begin asking users in the EU, European Economic Area (EEA), and Switzerland for consent before allowing targeted advertising on its networks. Before that, Meta defended its practices by arguing it had a "legitimate interest" to gather data, though regulators dismissed the claim.
Euractiv
Though the fines are scheduled to end on Nov. 3, Datatilsynet could make them permanent by referring its decision to the European Data Protection Board, which could broaden the scope of the rule to all of Europe.
Reuters
Even if Meta chooses not to abide by Norway's new rules and the fine was imposed for the entirety of the three-month ban, it would only add up to a fraction of 1% of the company's Q1 2023 profits.
The Register

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

Meta has clearly been deceitful in getting "permission" to track Norwegians' locations and other sensitive data, which is why the government's privacy regulator has had to step in. Vulnerable Facebook and Instagram users — most notably children — have unwittingly signed up to be watched by this tech giant, so it may be time for the entire continent to start fining Meta until it finally offers a genuine, easy-to-understand consent form.

Nsane Forums

Pro-establishment narrative

What regulators don't understand is that if they ban targeted advertising, the cost of social media would jump tremendously — and, obviously, the poor and less fortunate would be impacted most by those costs. We cannot forget how social media companies gave previously unheard people a voice and previously isolated people access to economic opportunity.