Beijing’s South China Sea claims ‘gravely undermine’ rule of law
Al JazeeraJan 13, 2022
Philippines Labels China an 'Aggressor' Amid Tensions in South China Sea
Photo: Jes Aznar [via Getty Images]
The Facts
As relations between the Philippines and Beijing deteriorate, the Southeast Asian US ally on Monday accused Chinese coastguard warships of "intentionally" colliding with two vessels while on a resupply mission in the disputed area near the Second Thomas Shoal — part of the Spratly Islands in the South China Sea.
Although no one was harmed, the incident in which a Chinese Coast Guard vessel collided with a small wooden Philippine resupply boat, sparked international outrage and expressions of concern from the US.
The Spin
Anti-China narrative
The PRC's activities in the South China Sea gravely undermine universally-recognized naval provisions under international law. Illegitimate activities include the deployment of China's so-called maritime militia in the waters near the Philippines, which harass and provoke Philippine fishermen and swarm parts of the sea within Manila's exclusive economic zone. Washington has rightfully stepped up its rhetoric and diplomatic efforts to challenge Beijing's provocative moves.
Pro-China narrative
The PRC has a historical claim over the South China Sea, and it's regulation of military activities in waters that are part of its exclusive economic zone is consistent with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea regulations. Washington is arbitrarily interpreting the convention, using political manipulation and double standards to provoke China for its own selfish interests.
Nerd narrative
There's a 15% chance that China and the US will be at war before 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.