Uyghur Refugee Dies After 9 Years of Thai Detention

Photo: Reuters [via Al Jazeera]

The Facts

  • Following the reported death of a second asylum seeker from China’s Muslim Uyghur minority in Thai custody within two months, human rights groups urged Thailand on Thursday to improve conditions in its immigration detention facilities.

  • Last Friday, 40-year-old Mattohti Mattursun died of suspected liver failure shortly after being taken to a hospital in Bangkok weeks after falling ill, prompting Human Rights Watch to call for an end to the Thai government's “inhumane and counterproductive” policy of indefinitely detaining people accused of violating immigration law.


The Spin

Anti-China narrative

Uyghurs, who are already oppressed in China, continue to face oppression in neighboring countries as they flee the PRC. Refugees are being subjected to inhumane conditions in Thai detention facilities. Thailand has even sent Uygher refugees back to China for them never to be heard from again. The unjust refugee and migration system must be reformed, and Beijing's policies must be questioned.

Pro-China narrative

Uyghurs leaving China has nothing to do with the fabricated "oppression" they face in China. All the claims about forced labor and the concern for human rights were invented by figures rabidly opposed to China in the US. Uyghurs live good lives in China, and any that exit the PRC make that choice due to other considerations.

Narrative C

Thailand's future elections may be a good opportunity for refugee advocates to advance their political objectives. Thailand is facing a migration crisis from multiple countries, with refugees pouring in from China and Myanmar and migrant workers streaming in from Cambodia and Laos. The next Thai government will hopefully prioritize human rights for migrants. Besides contributions to the economy, migrants should have a path to naturalization, which are all possible policies in the future.

Nerd narrative

There's a 15% chance that the UN will open an investigation or otherwise intervene on the issue of the Xinjiang internment camps before 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.


Establishment split

CRITICAL

PRO

More neutral establishment stance articles

Sign up to our daily newsletter