After the welfare vote debacle, this much is clear: Starmer must change. Labour MPs will demand it | Rafael Behr
Guardian1 day
UK: Welfare Reform Bill Passes After Further Government Concessions
Above: Protesters against welfare reforms in Parliament square on June 30, 2025 in London, England. Image copyright: Guy Smallman/Getty Images
The Spin
Left narrative
Starmer's last-minute welfare concessions prove the importance of Labour backbenches supporting grassroots movements; more must be done as the government continues to seek savings at the expense of the most vulnerable in society. While Labour's soul isn't dead yet, fundamental change is needed — Starmer must wake up to this reality or face continued challenges.
Right narrative
Starmer's capitulation to welfare rebels is a catastrophic failure of leadership. With benefits spiraling, the government can't even trim £5bn without backbench mutiny. This weakness signals open season for future rebellions while leaving taxpayers to compensate for those unwilling to work. It is clear that, while in government, it is the Labour left that is truly in power.