Trump's Gaza Security Plan Sparks Concern Over Clan Militias

Is Israel creating pathways to peace in Gaza or empowering criminal gangs to perpetuate occupation?

Published 13 hours ago

Trump's Gaza Security Plan Sparks Concern Over Clan Militias

story

Above: Islamic Jihad and Hamas militants transported a body bag presumed to contain the remains of an Israeli hostage in Beit Lahia, Northern Gaza Strip, on Dec. 3, 2025. Image credit: STR/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Israel's backing of anti-Hamas militias represents a pragmatic security strategy to dismantle terrorist control and create pathways for peace. These groups operate in Israeli-controlled zones, receive coordinated supplies and provide essential services to displaced families while actively opposing Hamas rule. The project aims to establish a "New Gaza" free from terrorism, offering Palestinians an alternative to Hamas and creating the conditions for reconstruction and stability.

Derrick Evans on X I24News The Telegraph

Pro-Palestine narrative

Empowering criminal gangs and IS-linked militants as security forces constitutes a catastrophic betrayal of Gaza's civilians. These groups are convicted drug traffickers, murderers and aid looters who torture Palestinians at checkpoints, steal humanitarian supplies and operate as Israeli intelligence assets. Hamas and the broader Palestinian public comprehensively reject these collaborators, recognizing them as tools designed to prevent Palestinian statehood while perpetuating occupation under the guise of security.

Trita Parsi on X Palestine Chronicle Middle East Monitor