Artificial Intelligence

UK Surgeon Performs First Remote Robotic Surgery From 1,500 Miles Away

Is robotic surgery a transformative platform or an overhyped technology lacking clinical evidence?

Published MAR 6

UK Surgeon Performs First Remote Robotic Surgery From 1,500 Miles Away

Story

Above: Medical professionals operate on a patient's heart with the first surgical robot in cardiac surgery at the German Heart Center at Charité in Berlin. Image credit: Manuel Genolet/Getty Images

The Facts

Professor Prokar Dasgupta reportedly performed the U.K.'s first remote robotic surgery on Feb. 11, operating on Paul Buxton, a 62-year-old prostate cancer patient in Gibraltar from The London Clinic in London, approximately 2,400 kilometers (1,491 miles) away.
The Times (UK)
The National Newspaper
The surgery utilized the Toumai Robotic System with a 3D high-definition camera and four arms, controlled via a console through fiber optics with a backup 5G connection, with only a 0.06-second time delay between London and Gibraltar.
Express.co.uk
Bournemouth Echo
Paul Buxton reported feeling "fantastic" four days after the operation and said participating was a "no-brainer," as it saved him from traveling to London and waiting three weeks on the NHS waiting list for treatment.
The Sun
BBC News
A medical team stood ready in Gibraltar's St Bernard's Hospital to take over the procedure as a precaution in case the internet connection failed during the operation, though the connection remained stable throughout.
guardian
LBC
Professor Dasgupta said the technology allows surgeons to "treat patients in remote areas," saving them the "vast expense and inconvenience" of traveling for care and providing access to specialized surgical expertise anywhere.
Belfast Telegraph
Upday News
Gibraltar Health Minister Gemma Arias-Vasquez called the procedure a "landmark moment," while The London Clinic's CEO Al Russell said the clinic hopes "more patients will benefit from this incredible medical breakthrough."
Independent
ITV News
Yahoo! News

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Techno-optimist narrative

Robotic surgery has evolved into a transformative platform that fundamentally changes surgical capability. The technology delivers unmatched exposure through immersive visualization and tenfold magnification, provides multiple "copilots" extending surgeon capabilities, and integrates emerging technologies like AI-driven tissue recognition and mixed-reality imaging, while offering superior ergonomics that enhance precision and control.

RyanCey on X

Peyman Sardari Nia on X

Techno-skeptic narrative

The hype around surgical robots ignores clinical reality and lacks quantitative evidence of meaningful improvement. Precision claims fail to demonstrate comparative value for most procedures, and fully autonomous soft tissue robotics remains nowhere near feasible. Current research shows robots handle maybe 5% of procedural steps while complications and liability questions remain unresolved.