Jimmy Lai Pleads Not Guilty in Hong Kong Sedition Trial

Photo: Pakkin Leung via Wikimedia Commons (Dec. 31, 2020)

The Facts

  • Hong Kong media mogul and prominent activist Jimmy Lai pleaded not guilty to the charges of conspiracy to commit foreign collusion and conspiring to publish seditious material as his national security trial resumed on Tuesday.

  • Meanwhile, in their opening arguments, prosecutors claimed that the defendant used his now-defunct Apple Daily news outlet to spread provocative content while collaborating with prominent foreign figures to lobby for sanctions and instigate hostility against Hong Kong and mainland China.


The Spin

Anti-China narrative

As the free world has known for a long time, the charges against Lai were always a sham — notably because he has been accused of sedition simply for talking to politicians and other activists. If Hong Kong wants to retain any of its past democratic dignity, Lai should be freed immediately. Otherwise, the Beijing-controlled courts will show once and for all that this is simply about crushing any dissenting voices.

Pro-China narrative

It's laughable that Western countries with similar — and even more vague — national security sedition laws are taking the moral high ground and claiming that this prosecution is politically motivated as if mainland China and Hong Kong weren't governed by the rule of law. There is no freedom in any country that allows bad actors to work directly with foreign powers against their homeland.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that Hong Kong will stop being a Special Administrative Region of China by Aug. 2046, according to the Metaculus prediction community.


Establishment split

CRITICAL

PRO

More neutral establishment stance articles

Sign up to our daily newsletter