Jordan

Jordan Peterson: Fight Against 'Re-Education' Has 'Barely Started'

JAN 18 2024·Updated JUL 3 2024

Story

Image credit: Chris Williamson/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

Canadian clinical psychologist Jordan Peterson has claimed that "the war has barely started" after losing a legal bid to have courts overturn a policy he described as a social media "re-education camp" ordered by the College of Psychologists of Ontario.
National Post
Three judges from the Ontario Court of Appeal on Tuesday dismissed Peterson's motion seeking for the case to be re-examined after an earlier hearing in a lower divisional court also went against him. The appeals court gave no reason.
National Post
Peterson gained attention in 2016 when he released a series of self-published YouTube videos explaining why he refused to comply with a newly-passed Canadian law requiring him, as a university professor, to address transgender students by their desired pronoun. Critics argued this was "transphobic," but he maintained that his quarrel wasn't about transgender rights but with a law allegedly violating his freedom of speech.
Newsweek
This latest dispute also centers around free speech, with the Ontario College of Psychologists — which Peterson has been a member of since 1999 — mandating him to undergo social media training following public comments he made. The complaint includes Peterson's criticisms of Canadian politicians, as well as social media posts about transgender actor Elliot Page and a plus-sized Sports Illustrated model.
CP24
In a divisional court hearing in August 2023, Peterson's argument that these were "off-duty" remarks was rejected by three judges. In the ruling, Justice Paul Schabas wrote that Peterson could not "have it both ways" and avoid the responsibility that comes with speaking from a "trusted capacity."
CP24
Peterson, who has exhausted all possible legal avenues, wrote on X there's "nothing [they] can take from me that I’m unwilling to lose." In a column for the National Post, he added that he has no regrets about his comments and would say them again.
National Post

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Left narrative

This ruling confirms that even when Peterson thinks he's off-duty, his remarks can still harm the public trust and confidence in his profession, particularly if those comments are degrading, demeaning, and unprofessional, as some of the complaints suggest. This was the right decision.

The Toronto Star

Right narrative

This is an outrageous affront to free speech. The College of Psychologists was wrong to try to exercise control over Peterson's opinions, and the courts were just as disgraceful in upholding this decision — effectively creating a re-education camp for political speech. This decision must be immediately reversed.

National Post