19 February 2024

Daily Newsletter

Russia Escalates Attacks as Ukraine Suffers Continued Ammo Shortages

The Facts

  • Following the fall of the Donetsk city of Avdiivka to Russian troops over the weekend, Russian forces have launched multiple attacks to the west of the city in an effort to secure further battlefield gains.

  • Russian forces have also intensified their efforts in numerous areas across the front line, according to the latest update from Ukraine's armed forces.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

The US passage of a $60B military aid package for Ukraine is a positive step towards addressing the issue of Kyiv's ammunition shortages, but it's just as important that European countries plug their own spending gaps and elevate their aid commitments. If Ukraine continues to fall short of ammunition and key supplies, it will face a slow-motion defeat on the battlefield that would spell disaster for the risk of future Russian expansionism against NATO.

Pro-Russia narrative

Following the avoidable loss of Ukrainian territory and men throughout this conflict, Ukraine's counteroffensive has now clearly failed. Committing further funding to arms will simply bring about more death and destruction. Ukraine would never have attempted to fight this war against Russia without US and EU weapons. Now that this support is running dry, Ukraine must accept the reality that Russia will never cease its defense of the Donbas or Crimea.

Nerd narrative

There is a 21% chance that Russia will have significantly expanded its controlled territory in Ukraine by January 1, 2026, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Von der Leyen to Seek Second Term as EC Head

The Facts

  • On Monday, during the Christian Democratic Union's (CDU) party conference in Berlin, Ursula von der Leyen declared her intention to run for a second, five-year term as president of the European Commission (EC).

  • On Saturday, Von der Layen had indicated her decision at the Munich Security Conference, claiming that, if she were to run again, she would emphasize increasing defense spending and appointing a defense commissioner.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Ursula von der Leyen was unanimously chosen by the CDU to remain as the executive commission's candidate. This decision sends a strong message to Europe, as the European Peoples Party (EPP), which is dominated by Christian Democrats, is anticipated to maintain its majority in the legislature following the European elections that take place in June. It's unlikely that any other candidate will be able to realistically challenge von der Leyen for the job.

Establishment-critical narrative

Ursula von der Leyen was confirmed by the EU Parliament and selected by EU leaders in 2019, lacking any form of democratic legitimacy. In the upcoming election, the European people will once again not vote on the Commission's executive. Rather, the political party with the highest percentage of votes will choose the presidency. Von der Leyen's path to remain commissioner is a glaring illustration of the EU's democratic shortcomings.

Nerd narrative

There is a 78% chance that the President of the European Commission will be affiliated with the EPP following the 2024 elections, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Yemen: US Strikes More Targets, Including Underwater Drone

The Facts

  • The US said it launched five airstrikes on Houthi-controlled territory in Yemen over the weekend — targeting three mobile cruise missiles, one unmanned surface vessel, and an unmanned underwater vehicle.

  • On Sunday, the US Central Command claimed that the weapons posed an "imminent threat" to US Navy ships and commercial vessels in the region. It also said it was the first time the Iran-aligned Houthis deployed an unmanned underwater vehicle since their Red Sea attacks began.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

While the Houthis claim that their operations are only directed against Israeli-linked commercial vessels, their attacks have disrupted maritime trade. Moreover, the Yemeni terrorists are being supported on the ground with weapons and intelligence by Tehran in its asymmetric war against Israel in violation of international law. Should Iran continue with its destabilizing and threatening tactics, the US must also consider direct strikes against the regime.

Establishment-critical narrative

Even the latest illegal aggression against Yemen will not deter the Houthis from continuing to attack the Israeli regime's maritime supply line. The US is deliberately causing the escalation in the Red Sea to distract from its direct support of Israel in its cruel campaign against the people of Gaza. However, Washington's calculation is not working out and instead represents a strategic blunder that only reinforces the regional isolation of the US and Israel.

Nerd narrative

There is a 13% chance, that the US and Iran will be primary actors on opposite sides of a war before 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Report: Navalny's Body Found Bruised in Arctic Morgue

The Facts

  • Russian opposition media Novaya Gazeta Europe has reported, quoting an unidentified paramedic, that the body of recently deceased Alexei Navalny had bruises on the head and chest when he was allegedly brought to the Salekhard District Clinical Hospital for an autopsy.

  • According to the self-described experienced paramedic, these injuries would be consistent with those from attempts to hold down a convulsing individual as well as from an indirect cardiac massage.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

As more information emerges, the world will move from assuming this was an assassination to knowing it was. Putin, who chose to commit this murder around the time of the NATO security conference, has a long history of destroying all opposition. He won't be stopped until someone in his own orbit or from outside of Russia decides to rid the world of his dictatorial regime.

Pro-Russia narrative

The West has been pushing unproven propaganda about Navalny since the so-called assassination attempt in 2020. Now, with their self-proclaimed "opposition leader" having died of unknown causes, the anti-Russia powers that be will again spread unfounded rhetoric and accusations. The autopsy hasn't even been conducted and Western powers are already drawing fallacious conclusions.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that Vladimir Putin will cease to hold the office of President of Russia by December 2028, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Papua New Guinea: Tribal Violence Kills at Least 26

The Facts

  • As many as 26 people were killed during an ambush in the Enga province in the northern highlands of Papua New Guinea on Sunday.

  • Authorities had initially announced that at least 64 people had died from the fighting, then corrected the figure, but the incident is still believed to be the worst massacre in the country's recent history. The deceased bodies were reportedly seen being loaded onto a truck.


The Spin

Narrative A

As its highlands have long struggled with violence, internal security, more broadly, remains a key concern for PNG. However, the failure of the state to prevent the influx of illegal high-powered firearms and ammunition into the region has exacerbated the conflict and made clashes deadlier. The latest ambush has renewed attention to Prime Minister Marape's incompetence in providing grassroots solutions. If he can't prevent massacres of unprecedented intensity, Marape should step down.

Narrative B

Tribal violence isn't uncommon in PNG, however, police couldn't foresee it and had limited resources to deal with Sunday's massive ambush. In their quest for revenge killing and retribution, these tribes are breaking the law and creating instability. Marape's government is striving to curb the security issues and coordinating with community leaders to defuse tensions. Until the warring factions lay down their weapons, these long-held disputes will remain unresolved.

See sources

PRC Offers to Deepen Security, Law-Enforcement With Hungary

The Facts

  • China has reportedly offered Hungary deeper law enforcement and security ties, including combating terrorism. This comes as the two nations honor 75 years of their diplomatic relationship.

  • Chinese Public Security Minister Wang Xiaohong met Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban on Feb. 16 and hoped to strengthen their coordination in "international and regional affairs."


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

Hungary and China are showing the world how a bilateral relationship based on trust and mutual respect can be beneficial to both the parties involved. China's offer now to further deepen their strategic ties indicates that the two nations' warming is gaining steam. Together, the leaders of the two nations are shaping a comprehensive partnership that will be a truly multi-polar model for the world to follow.

Pro-establishment narrative

Hungary's "Eastern Opening" policy, which has led to its newfound love for China, could be leading the country towards disaster. This also endangers the EU by giving Beijing a dangerous foothold in Europe. Frequently criticized for his authoritarian tendencies, Orban has found a willing partner in China, while Beijing may be keen on using Hungary's key position in the EU to swing matters in a concerning geopolitical direction on the world stage.

Nerd narrative

There is a 15% chance that Hungary will leave the EU by 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Israel Warns of Rafah Assault by Ramadan

The Facts

  • Israel has warned that if Hamas doesn't release Israeli hostages by March 10, the beginning of the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, then it will invade the southern Gazan city of Rafah. Foreign Minister Benny Gantz said Gaza can "celebrate Ramadan" if Hamas surrenders and releases the "abductees."

  • This follows Defense Minister Yoav Gallant's statement that the military was already preparing to target the city of 1M people, which is also currently housing upwards of 1.3M displaced Palestinians. While Israel hasn't offered specific plans, one defense official said they would have to screen each civilian before sending them north to tent cities; another said they could make a floating jetty to import humanitarian aid.


The Spin

Pro-Palestine narrative

What Israel is currently doing to Palestine is nothing new. Going back to Israel's ethnic cleansing of Palestinians during the 1948 Nakba, Israel's goal has always been to displace and kill civilians through starvation and military assaults to achieve its goal of complete dominance over the region. Based on historical precedent, there is a tremendous concern for Rafah if Israel isn't told to stop.

Pro-Israel narrative

As far as historical precedent is concerned, Hamas has a long history of luring mass groups of Palestinians into tightly packed cities — this time Rafah — so that it can later blame Israel when civilians die in the crossfire. Both Israel and the Palestinian Authority have called for a cease-fire in exchange for a hostage release, but Hamas is hindering these efforts through its continued attacks and flagrant use of human shields.

Nerd narrative

There's a 59% chance that Israel will have de facto power in the Gaza Strip on Jan. 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Argentina: Concerns Mount Over Offshore Marine Life

The Facts

  • Politicians and environmentalists from the Falkland Islands have recently raised concerns over resource exploitation in the rich and biodiverse disputed ocean waters known as the "Blue Hole" just off the coast of Argentina.

  • The boundary that stretches 200 miles (321 km) from shore designating Argentina's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) bisects the Blue Hole. The eastern side lies in international waters and is unregulated; Argentine and foreign vessels harvest this area for its rich marine life.


The Spin

Narrative A

In March 2023, the UN was successful in getting nearly 200 countries to agree to and sign a global "High Seas Treaty." The treaty is meant to provide legal tools to enforce laws and regulations applied to marine fisheries and protected areas against mining, overfishing, and other activities that could deplete the rich biodiversity of the oceans. This is a huge win in preserving oceans and protecting marine life and must be enforced in areas like offshore Argentina.

Narrative B

Despite the signing of the High Seas Treaty, it's very unlikely that such a robust regulation mechanism will be ratified. The treaty must be ratified by 60 countries before implementation can occur. Countries like Russia stand in the way of ratification because, while not blocking the signing, Moscow has clearly stated that it finds the treaty to be "unacceptable." Without major nations signing on, there's little hope that others will follow suit, and areas like the Blue Hole will be in peril.

Nerd narrative

There's a 53% chance that the Billion Oyster Project restore will 1 billion oysters to New York Harbor before 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Launches $400 Sneaker Line

The Facts

  • Former US Pres. Donald Trump made a surprise appearance at Sneaker Con in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania., on Saturday, during which he unveiled the limited edition "Never Surrender high-tops" for $399 per pair.

  • The website selling the shoes, which the Trump campaign says is not connected to them, also posted Victory47 cologne and perfume for $99 per bottle — a reference to Trump becoming the 47th president if he were to win reelection.


The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

Proven by the licensing address of this shoe manufacturer being the same as one of his golf resorts, Donald Trump is tied financially to the sale of these shoes. However, despite his efforts to pretend that this isn't a scheme to bring in income after losing yet another multi-million-dollar lawsuit, the only result of this cynical stunt is the continued trivialization of his legal losses.

Pro-Trump narrative

Donald Trump has never lost his supporters because he does what old-fashioned Republicans would never do — not give up. As Democrats seek to win by trying to put their primary political opponent in jail, Trump continues to meet regular Americans where they are and provide to them about what they care about. Donald Trump isn't the one trivializing the weaponized justice system — he's the one poking fun at its institutional rot.

Nerd narrative

There’s a 51% chance that Trump would win a 2024 presidential election matchup with Biden, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Wisconsin: Governor Signs GOP Redistricting Map

The Facts

  • Democratic Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers signed new legislative district maps drawn by the majority-Republican legislature on Monday. Following over a decade of unchallenged Republican maps, the Democrats are now likely to gain more seats in the 2024 election.

  • This comes after the election of the liberal state Supreme Court Justice Janet Protasiewicz in August flipped the balance of the bench and allowed the court to rule the Republicans' original maps unconstitutional. The court said it would draw the lines if no maps Evers would sign could be passed.


The Spin

Democratic narrative

The old Republican-drawn maps turned the state into a slice of Swiss cheese, carving out detached districts to ensure the GOP always won big. While the Republicans may still achieve a majority in the upcoming election, the state will look a lot more representative than in the past. Democrats should celebrate this historic win against gerrymandering and work hard to capitalize on the actual representative democracy the people have been asking for.

Republican narrative

Wisconsin's maps were deemed appropriate for years under the supervision of state courts and legislatures as well as federal courts. It was only after Protasiewicz — who, in an unprecedented fashion, campaigned on ordering a redraw — was elected that their fairness was questioned. The sad irony here is that Wisconsin Democrats have just used court-ordered gerrymandering in their so-called fight against gerrymandering.

Establishment-critical narrative

Both Democrats and Republicans gerrymander massively, making American democracy far from fair. Election laws should change.

See sources

NBA All-Star Game Breaches Historic Scoring Milestone

The Facts

  • The NBA All-Star Game saw the first team in league history to score 200 or more points in a single game as the Eastern Conference took down the Western Conference in Sunday’s battle.

  • The typically high-scoring event ended with the East winning 211 to 186 and Damian Lillard of the Milwaukee Bucks taking home the game's Most Valuable Player award MVP.


The Spin

Narrative A

For many years the NBA All-Star Game has been essentially unwatchable, but Sunday’s debacle took the event to a new level. With an absurd 97 pointers attempted, it's clear that none of the players care one iota about the game. Careening through the historic point barrier is unacceptable. Adam Silver has tried many different twists to reignite the exhibition game, but after this performance, this event can't be saved.

Narrative B

Amid the controversy, the NBA All-Star Game saw history be made, and the exhibition was filled with highlights and fascinating moments. Obviously, the match doesn't have the same fire as a normal game, but the beauty of the All-Star Game is showcasing the league's brightest stars all on one stage. At the end of the day, a historic record fell — All-Star Weekend is about fun, and the contest is filled with it.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that Wilt Chamberlain's single-game NBA scoring record will be broken before at least January 1, 2050, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter